Wednesday, April 11, 2007

I Couldn't Love Her More If She Was My Own Child!

I remember that night.

It was 16 years ago, and it was our second date.

"I can't father children due to the therapy I had for cancer as a teenager," said my good looking, handsome, nice, straight, employed date.

I remember the night we got engaged.

"How about artificial insemmination?" I asked.

"No, thanks," said my good looking, handsome, nice, straight, employed fiance.

We did give it a whirl 5 years later after a couple of dizzying roller coaster rides on the domestic adoption front, but my heart wasn't really into it. I went to homestudy classes and listened with incredulity as women bared their souls about the crushing pain of infertility.

"I had to run out of my niece's christening because I was bawling," said one.

"I can't go to baby showers. Don't even ask." said another.

I looked properly sympathetic, but inside I was thinking how very, very different and weird I was. The idea of being pregnant didn't fill me with much of anything except abject terror, and knowing that I could never recreate a little RogerLorrie anyway made it easy to pursue the path that we followed.

I also never had an attack of "I am adopted, I need to see my face on somebody else." (shrug) I'm not being falsely modest here, but I never thought my face needed to be recreated on another innocent human being.

So I've been following the debate that rages on A Little Pregnant, Chicago Mama, Figlet, etc. with great interest and lots of feelings, but I'm having an uncharacteristically hard time trying to figure out if I can add anything to the debate that I (much less any of your poor innocent readers) would find new, or interesting, or significant.

Because the first thing that I believe about all this is that:

We are all different.

I can't take the moral high ground because for me deciding to pursue adoption was almost effortless. I wasn't beset with doubts about could I love another's child as my own--I had noticed that my adoptive mother and father had no problems with this and figured, correctly, that I wouldn't either.

I did not care what race my child was, but I also understand people who want a child who looks like them, and frankly it never occurred to me that my child might want to look like her parents. (It should have). In 1998, China was the go-to program for adoption---devoid of corruption, fairly easy (ha! It must be like labor pains--you forget the hours of backbreaking paperwork and the torturous wait, now stretching into eternity it seems) and yes...I wanted a daughter. Real Real Real Bad. I also wanted a child that had probably not been exposed to drugs/alcohol.

The second thing I believe is:

I agree with the adoptive mothers who are upset over the casual putdowns of adoption by people who haven't done it.

I mean, I've never experienced labor pain, and I wouldn't go around telling pregnant women about my how sister in law's third cousin screamed and screamed for thirty-six hours and got all tore up and etc. I wouldn't tell them that adoption is so much easier because after all, you don't end up with stretch marks and other unpleasant reminders of childbirth, yet so many people seem willing to spread horror stories about somebody they know who had a terrible experience with adoption, ergo, it's a bad thing.

Look, if YOU could never love another person's baby as your own, that's fine, but can you understand how hard it is for an adopted child to hear that? Can you understand how painful it is for me to think that my parents would have loved the product of their loins more than ME? I mean, how on earth could any child be more wonderful than I AM? I ASK YOU.

Can you understand how hard it is for us adoptive parents? Can you understand that we're dreading the day our child comes home from ballet practice asking us about an offhand comment that they heard in the car pool line along these terms? Can you understand that we lie awake at night worrying that our child will someday lie awake at night asking themselves, "Did they settle for me? Did they reluctantly give up the dream of a blonde blue eyed angel with their smile for me? Do they secretly regret that I can't do algebra or throw a football as well as they can and think that perhaps their OWN child would have lived up to their hopes and dreams?"

And the third thing I believe is that:

I, personally, am glad I adopted and I hope with all my heart that you, dear reader, find your path, whatever it may be.

Peace.

36 comments:

Dirk said...

You made me cry.

And you said so well what I wish I could have written.

But the thing that touched me the most is what you said about the fear that our children might ever worry whether we would have loved biological children more. That breaks my heart.

Johnny said...

Yay!

Stephanie said...

That was beautiful. Your children are blessed to have such a loving mother.

Miss Cellania said...

Bravo! I never cared much one way or another about being pregnant, but I really wanted children. Now, like you, my biggest concern is how they feel, 'cause I am totally happy they came into my life. There is a lot of guilt about the way things have turned out so far, but I can't imagine life without them.

Figlet said...

Nice.

Deborah said...

Thanks for this.

AA said...

Great post.I agree with everything you said.

It wasn't hard for me to choose adoption either. Seems it was always in my head at some level anyway. My son does look like me and in some ways that is a good thing, but it also makes it harder when people are SSSOOO surprised that he is adopted.

I have given birth (to a son that died at 1 year from bacterial meningitis, and let me tell you there is just as much pain and it is far scarier to go down the adoption path. After seeing him and falling in love with him, I spent the next 5 months scared to death that something would happen to keep him from me.

It all worked out. He is the world's greatest child! And I can say with authority, there is no difference in how much you love them. At least not for me. Biology makes absolutely no difference in the depth of my love. But, I never thought it would.

Perrin said...

You said it well, as usual. I agree, a special dose of peace to those struggling to find their way.

Elisabeth said...

I very much enjoy hearing what you have to say about adoption, particularly because you have experienced both sides of it. My husband is adopted, and although adoption isn’t a new concept for me (my uncle and a few cousins are adopted), I find his/his family’s outlook on it completely different then how my family looked at it. I find that I have to be much more sensitive about some things and less so about others. I find your blog to be insightful and, even though the adoption experience seems to vary from individual to individual (even my husband and his sister see things very, very differently), helpful in understanding things that I hadn’t considered before.

Thanks!

Sandra said...

That was an amzing post, Lorrie - thanks for this. I couldn't have said it better.

erin said...

I have a bio boy and two girls from China. People ask me all the time if my son is my "real son". How oh how could you let my daughter hear that she isn't my real daughter?

Donna said...

THANK YOU for the most intelligent post on this particular topic that I've read all week (it's being discussed EVERYWHERE, it seems).

Donna
Our blog: Double Happiness!

Anonymous said...

When DH & I were doing the infertility thing, I realized after only a few months of "treatment" that what I truly wanted was to love and raise a child. Pregnancy, childbirth, a genetic connection...those didn't seem very important to me. Given my age at the time (ahem, let's just say I was closer to 40 than 30), adoption seemed like like it offered the best odds at transforming me into what I wanted to be: A Mom.

We adopted a beautiful girl from China. I'm convinced our daughter is far superior to any child that would have resulted from a combination of our own DNA, which is rife with anxiety/depression/bad eyesight/horrible acne/crappy tickers/poor athleticism, etc. I just pray that her natural cheerful, glass-half-full personality helps buoy her up as she integrates her adoption into her identity.

Thanks for your post, Lorrie.

sign me,
anon

Oopsy Daisy said...

I couldn't have said it better myself. I may have to put you in my new book!

velocibadgergirl said...

Fantastic, fantastic entry.

Applause from another happy adoptee.

Anonymous said...

Very nice post. Well said.

Only one thing--when I was pregnant (and my pregnant friends will also attest to this), people were absolutely not shy about telling me horror stories about their sister-in-law's 48 hour labor, 15 weeks of bedrest, emergency c-section, baby in the NICU, and on and on and on. Oh, and when they found out I was planning on not taking any painkillers during labor, they would say, "Ha! Take my advice honey, get the epidural." Yeah. A lot of people just don't seem to think all that much...

leigh said...

THIS is the kind of post that an argument such as this needs. No vitriol thrown about, no slamming of those who don't realize* that the questions they ask and the things they 'know' to be true are in fact ignorant and hurtful. You spelled out your concerns and hurt in a respectful manner that taught me something. Well done.

*I am choosing to give most commenters/posters the benefit of the doubt. Let's face it, someone who is asking if you can love an adopted child as much as 'your own' most likely is honestly wondering if they themselves could, and a post such as this will go a long way to opening their eyes to 'the other side'.

Old_Lady said...

I am a biological child from a large family (at least by modern standards). I got pregnant easily, even after 40, but was filled with abject fear about all the things I've have to do to deliver a full-term baby. At every phase in my adult life, I've known a child that was adopted from Korea. It's as if God had placed these huge road signs in my path from about age 18 on up telling me that THIS was how I would become a mother. It was a very easy decision to say "to hell with pregnancy and childbirth." (And hey, I really DIDN'T want to pass on some of my lesser genes, or create another person that looks like me - yuck.) It was an easy decision to adopt. And, damn, I knew I'd be able to love someone else's birthchild as my own the first time I adopted a little canine child.

Brooklyn Mama said...

Rock on, Lorrie.

Old_Lady said...

I just read my own comment and realized I sounded like I might have had an abortion. No way. Try the tendency to miscarry early on. I was told that it was bedrest all the way for me. Nevertheless, I consider myself an adopter by choice, because I never experienced a moment's doubts or misgivings or sorrow about the decision not to give birth. Rock on, Lorrie!

atomic mama said...

Can I hear a "Hell, yee-ay-uh!" Thanks for this.

TBG Happenings said...

hell, yee-ay-uh!!!!

FDChief said...

Sadly, the world will never lack for people stupid enough to say all the sorts of things you mentioned. Fortunately, there are a few people, like you, Lorrie, who can give us the other side: thoughtful, well-written - you touched 'em all with this one.

Tip your hat. You deserve it.

Mirjam said...

Time to delurk.

Doin' the wave here. GREAT post! Very, very well-written.

Mirjam
The Netherlands
Mom to one from the loins (now that's a keeper) and one from China, and loving them both to pieces.

CJ said...

When my son was about a year old, there was a local failed adoption case in the news. The birth father had never signed off on the adoption and before it was completely finalized, said he wanted the baby back. It was heartbreaking for the adoptive family.

A childless co-worker said, "Those people should have just given that baby back. It wasn't even theirs. I don't know why they've fought for this long to keep it!"

I looked at her and said, "I'm going to forgive you for saying that, because you don't have children. I'm telling you right now, it doesn't matter where the baby came from - your uterus or someone else's, when someone hands you a baby and say 'It's yours' - it is."

She shut up and walked away.

Lene said...

What a great post! New reader...I will be back to vist.

BTW, your daughter is beautiful! What a smile!

Lene said...

What a great post! New reader...I will be back to vist.

BTW, your daughter is beautiful! What a smile!

Anonymous said...

New reader here ... I will stick around for more! I am a birthmom and also an adoptive mom (no more bio kids after my only pregnancy due to a post-IUD infection). I have to say my two (adopted) daughters are the light of my life, and I always think there is no way on earth I could have produced such amazing children myself ... although I have also had the good fortune to be reunited with the adult child I placed for adoption (I was a teenager when I found myself pregnant and it was 1966 - not a very good era to be in that situation), and she's pretty awesome, too ... as is her wonderful family. You are on the mark when you point out the insensitivity of many who don't understand the adoption-created family. What has always been matter-of-fact for my chidren might be foreign and strange to others. Our daughter came home the first day of kindergarten telling us she felt "sorry for all the kids in her class." Why? we asked. "Because none of them have birthmothers!" She has never had the opportunity to meet her birthmother, but we have always presented her in the most positive light ... so she was surprised to find that other kids didn't have that. As I'm sure the other kids were to discover she did have a birthmother.

Anonymous said...

Can I just say that when I got pregnant with my son, I worried that I could love him as much as I did as my adopted, first daughter?

Miss Cellania said...

Have you heard of the Thinking Blogger Awards? You have been tagged!

Pissed OFF Housewife said...

Go Mom.

You can't unring the bell and there are words that should never be uttered.

Tammie said...

I found your blog through one of my friend's own blog. I really enjoyed this post & will be back.

Right as my husband & I started dating, I found out I would never get pregnant. I told this in all honesty to the man I have loved since I was 19 years old. It didn't phase him. His answer was that we would adopt. Nevertheless, I always felt "broken" in some strange ways.

When we finally decided to start proceedings for a China adoption, I realized that I wasn't broken. It was G-d's way of bringing me on a different journey to parenthood. My daughter is my life's dream. We both have brown hair & eys. Our smiles are huge from ear to ear. You mean she didn't come from me!? I'd never know.

Your words were very powerful & spoke to me. I too worry about the foolish comments that may one day hurt her as they hurt me now.

A Grand mother in Waiting said...

Thank you for one of the best blogs I have ever read. Bless you.

41 years ago when my husband & I discussed our future, we talked about children and the "what if we can't get pregnant"? Both of us easily said we would adopt. We never went down that road, only because we had 3 biological children...not because we never wanted to. Our oldest child, our daughter and her husband are in the looonnnnggg process of adopting a baby (hopefully twins) from China. I am often asked, "aren't they able to have their own children". I am usually caught off guard and never prepared to answer. Actually, they have never "tried" to have a baby, but they still chose to adopt. Not because they can or cannot have a child biologically. I believe they saw a need and they had the means to adopt...when I say that, I do not mean the financial means...they have hearts big enough and egos small enough to do it. Having someone who looks like them or handing down the "genes" is not important to them. Being a family and loving and nuturing a family is.

Alyson & Ford said...

Love your post.
We will love our daughter equally with our biological children (all grown and married). We will be much more open to our new daughter's personality as we will not be looking for "us" in her. She is brand new to us.
We love her as she IS our child.
Thank you for the wonderful writings....

Alyson

Colleen said...

Came here from TrancJen's blog. Here's hoping that the pills are working.

As an adoptee I just want to say thank you for continuing this long & (occasionally anyway) proud tradition. And to Erin I give permission to use my response to anybody who uses the word "real" to describe a parent or child...the real parents are the people who raise the child..the ones who kiss boo-boos and potty train and sit through driving lessons and pay for college and weddings. The real child is the one who is loved and treasured by his or her real parents. The birth parents are the ones who contributed DNA and carried the child to term. They are important and I thank God for them. But they are not the "REAL" parents.

Seriously...I have interrupted conversations that I have overheard to give this speech. Some people don't appreciate it, but I really don't care.

Bassette said...

We have highlighted your blog with an excerpt from this entry at TAO Forum Network,... www.taoforumnetwork.com

It's always interesting to read the perspectives of those who hold two triad positions. As an adoptive parent I am always interested in reading the perspective of adopted adults and it's even MORE interesting when they are also adoptive parents.

Thanks for sharing!